Ombudsman Supports Theft Claimant in Home Business Coverage Dispute

1

The policyholder initially applied for coverage in August 2022, designating her property for "private use." However, IAG contested this, asserting that she had registered her business at the same location in September 2021. The insurer claimed that the woman's home served as the base for her online business, which purportedly involved managing 15 employees and engaging in wholesale goods.

In her defence, the claimant argued that she was truthful when procuring the insurance, claiming she did not operate any business activities onsite at the time of policy inception. According to her account, the business address was used solely for Australian Business Number registration purposes, and her business operations were conducted elsewhere. She further substantiated her claim by providing documentation that showed stock deliveries were made to her ex-husband's address, not her rental property.

AFCA noted that IAG's allegations primarily relied on inferred conclusions drawn from the policyholder's tax documentation and business registration rather than concrete, current operational evidence. According to the ombudsman, the insurer's evidence emerged months after the policy was issued, lacking immediate records of business activity at the rental property.

In its ruling, AFCA concluded that the insurer failed to present sufficient evidence to support its accusation of fraudulent behaviour. The ombudsman highlighted that a company's registered address does not inherently reflect active business operations at that location. Given the circumstances, AFCA advised IAG to reassess its decision, reinstate the woman's policy, and honour her theft claim.

This ruling underscores the nuanced considerations involved when insurers assess the validity of policyholder claims concerning home business disclosures.

Published:Monday, 30th Jun 2025
Source: Paige Estritori

Share this news item:

Insurance News

Clear

AFCA Sides with Policyholder in Storm Damage Dispute 18 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori A recent ruling by the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) has favoured a policyholder in a dispute with insurer Auto & General over storm damage. The case involved a collapsed ceiling, initially attributed to a storm by the insurer before an about-face led them to deny the claim. The AFCA decision marks a significant instance where consumer protection mechanisms have countered an insurer's attempt to deny coverage. - read more

Transforming Home Insurance: The Rise of the Home Energy Revolution 17 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori The landscape of home insurance policies in Australia stands on the brink of transformation as an increasing number of homes, apartment complexes, and small businesses are projected to integrate solar panels and battery systems by 2050. According to a report from the actuarial consultancy Finity, these homes will evolve into independent power stations, generating and storing their own electricity, marking a pivotal shift in home energy management. - read more

Life Insurers Reevaluate Amid Rising Mental Health Claims 16 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori In a growing industry concern, the Council of Australian Life Insurers has highlighted an alarming increase in mental health-related claims, which are now the leading cause of total and permanent disability (TPD) claims. The rise has driven insurers to reconsider their current practices and strategies to address this trend. - read more

QBE Highlights the Importance of Adequate Landlord Insurance 15 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori Landlords in Australia have been advised by QBE Insurance Group to reassess their insurance coverage, following survey findings that indicate many could encounter financial hardships if their rental operations are interrupted. According to QBE's data, 38% of landlords might face financial challenges should their properties become uninhabitable or rental payments cease for a duration of two to six weeks. - read more

Court Denies E-Scooter Negligence Allegation Against City Council 14 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori An Australian court recently ruled in favour of the City of Joondalup, rejecting a negligence claim lodged by an injured e-scooter rider. The Western Australia District Court found the city not liable for an accident involving insurance broker Kirstin Leibbrandt, who collided with a fence post while riding an e-scooter in the Perth suburb of Hillarys. - read more